In this April Fools' Day clip show special, Penn and Teller educate the audience about the nature of their show, analyze how some of the "foolers" fooled them, catch one in a unique lie, and bring back another to "explain" his trick.
Matt Marcy does a presentation on his card trick. Vintage act The Sentimentalists guess an image. Andrew Evans has his friend Naomi levitate. Don Chambers pulls beer out of thin air. Penn and Piff the Magic Dragon sing a guessing song.
Rematch with "foolers": Gilbert Gottfried helps Vinny Grosso with a stuffed trick, Morgan and West do a trick that adds up, Paul Gertner does a card guessing trick, Eric Jones plays with flaming coins, and Penn and Teller misdirect us.
Music magician Ryan Chandler, coin magician Ryan Hayashi, German veteran levitation magician Dirk Losander, and scientist magician Ed Ripley hope to fool the veteran duo. Also, Penn and Teller use a magic box to full us.
Magicians Danny Cole, returning champion Kostya Kimlat, Swedish magician-musician Hakan Berg, and John Michael Hinton try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks. Also, Penn and Teller tell the sad magic story of Prisoner 42799.
Psychology student and amateur mentalist Emily Victoria, sentimental German magician Patrick Folkerts, card illusionist Migz, and edgy escape artist Seth Grabel try to fool Penn and Teller. Also, Kim Raver pulls an egg from their sack.
Taijyi Fujryama from Japan, Pit Hartling from Germany, Helen Coghlan from Australia, and Menny Lindenfeld from Israel try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks. Also, Penn and Teller play a guessing game with mint containers.
Funnyman Erik Tait plays invisible cards, Rebecca Herrera guesses which shape Teller drew, Japanese comedian TanBA eats razors and balloons, Alyson fires crossbows at Ian Stewart, and P&T ask rock star Dan Reynolds to follow their lead.
Damien James' P&T puppets guess a card, Kelvin Chow's cards are magic, Joshua Lozoff and Alyson guess an animal, historian Murray Sawchuck performs Mr. Electric's classic, and Penn and Teller create a card trick for the ages - literally.
It's Will Bradshaw vs. animal traps, mentalist Eric Dittelman masters double entendre, Christian Engblom makes cards vanish, Compagnie des Dragonfly mix up their assistants and comedian Tom Green helps Penn with Teller's gambling problem.
Tech magician Simon Pierro 3D-prints a celebrity, shock magician Nicholas Wallace feeds blindfolded Alyson deadly cookies, Darcy Oake teleports a card into a bottle, Alex Geiser pushes coins through glass and P&T help a girl levitate.
Tyler Twombly plays with stickers, Dr. Michael Rubinstein has coins from La quatrième dimension (1959), shock magician Anastasia Synn uses her body modifications, co-creator of Siri, Adam Cheyer, turns Siri into cards, and Penn hides in a barrel.
French card magician Alexandra Duvivier, ventriloquist Christine Barger, her mentalist doll and Scott 'Carrot Top' Thompson, high tech magician Jamie Allan, and phone mentalist Christopher Grace try to fool the veteran duo. Also, Penn counts cards.
Magician Kiko Pastur does a card trick for Alyson, Jason Palter can measure any distance instinctively, Michael Gee does a card trick with his toy car, Bryan Saint creates a magical infomercial, and the boys teach kids to guess colors.